Canadian Recommendation on Screening for PPD Misses the Mark

Postpartum/perinatal despair (PPD) stays the commonest complication in trendy obstetrics, with a prevalence of 10%-15% based mostly on a number of research over the past 2 many years. Over those self same 2 many years, there was rising curiosity and motivation throughout the nation – from small group hospitals to main tutorial facilities – to advertise screening. Such screening is built-in into obstetrical practices, usually utilizing the Edinburgh Postnatal Melancholy Scale (EPDS), essentially the most broadly used validated display for PPD globally.

As talked about in earlier columns, the U.S. Preventive Companies Job Pressure really helpful screening for PPD in 2016, which incorporates screening ladies at highest threat, and each acutely treating and stopping PPD.

Since then, screening ladies for a typical scientific drawback like PPD has been broadly adopted by clinicians representing a broad spectrum of interdisciplinary care. Suppliers who’re engaged within the therapy of postpartum ladies – obstetricians, psychiatrists, doulas, lactation consultants, facilitators of postpartum assist teams, and advocacy teams amongst others – are included.

Lee S. Cohen, MD

An open query and considered one of nice concern not too long ago to our group and others has been what occurs after screening. It’s clear that identification of PPD per se just isn’t essentially a problem, and we’ve got a number of efficient remedies from antidepressants to mindfulness-based cognitive remedy to cognitive-behavioral interventions. There may be additionally a rising variety of digital purposes geared toward mitigation of depressive signs in ladies with postpartum main depressive dysfunction. One unanswered query is learn how to interact ladies after identification of PPD and learn how to facilitate entry to care in a manner that maximizes the chance that girls who really are affected by PPD get satisfactory therapy.

The “perinatal therapy cascade” refers back to the majority of ladies who, on the opposite facet of identification of PPD, fail to obtain satisfactory therapy and proceed to have persistent despair. That is maybe the best problem to the sphere and to clinicians – how will we, on the opposite facet of screening, see that these ladies get entry to care and get nicely?

With that backdrop, it’s shocking that the Canadian Job Pressure on Preventive Well being Care has not too long ago really helpful towards screening with systematic questionnaires, noting that advantages had been unclear and never a specific benefit relative to straightforward apply. The advice carries an assumption that commonplace apply entails queries about psychological well being. Whereas the duty drive continues to suggest screening for PPD, their suggestion towards screening with a standardized questionnaire represents a daring, sweeping, if not myopic view.

Whereas the Canadian Job Pressure on Preventive Well being Care made their suggestion based mostly on a single randomized managed trial with the belief that girls had been getting psychological well being counseling, and that girls favored getting psychological well being engagement round their despair, that isn’t a uniform a part of apply. Thus, it’s puzzling why the duty drive would make the advice based mostly on such sparse knowledge.

The best way to optimize entry to care and referral programs for ladies who’re affected by PPD is to not take away part of the system that is already working. Effectively-validated questionnaires such because the EPDS are simple to manage and are routinely built-in into the digital well being programs data of each small and huge facilities. These questionnaires are a cheap approach to improve the chance that girls get recognized and referred for a spectrum of probably useful interventions.

PPD can also be simple to deal with with medicines and a large spectrum of nonpharmacologic interventions. Novel interventions are additionally being explored to maximise entry for ladies with postpartum temper and anxiousness problems akin to peer-delivered behavioral activation and cognitive-behavioral remedy, which could possibly be group based mostly and applied from city to rural settings throughout the USA.

What may have the best research is the trail to accessing efficient remedies and sources for these ladies and this drawback has prompted our group to discover these points in our extra latest investigations. Higher understanding of these elements that restrict entry to psychological well being suppliers with experience in perinatal psychological well being to the logistical problems with navigating the well being care system for sleep-deprived new mothers and their households calls for higher consideration and clearer solutions.

The entire subject has an obligation to postpartum ladies to determine the amalgam of practitioners, sources, and platforms that should be used to have interaction ladies in order that they get efficient therapy – as a result of we’ve got efficient remedies. However the resolution to bettering perinatal psychological well being outcomes, in contrast to the method of our colleagues in Canada, is to not be present in abandoning questionnaire-based screening, however in figuring out one of the best methods to forestall PPD and to maximise entry to care.

Dr. Cohen is the director of the Ammon-Pinizzotto Middle for Girls’s Psychological Well being at Massachusetts Common Hospital (MGH) in Boston, which offers info sources and conducts scientific care and analysis in reproductive psychological well being. He has been a advisor to producers of psychiatric medicines. E mail Dr. Cohen at

This text initially appeared on, a part of the Medscape Skilled Community.

Categorized as News

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *